Midway Pizza

Reviews

• Anne M.

  star star star star star_border 6 August 2026

  There are opposing reviews fir this place but it seemed slightly more than half were very positive so I opted to try it. I ran in this place after walking my dogs at Bluff Pt State Park. The woman there greeted me immediately & took my order. She was very nice, efficient & helpful. I ordered a 6" steak bomb. I ordered it with provolone instead of American cheese which they happily obliged. I ordered it dry (without LTM). It took a 5-6 minutes bc they fry it on the flattop & then put it in the pizza oven to lightly toasty it which was great. The sub was solidly good. They use red peppers instead of green which is awesome. (I am not a big fan of green peppers). They didn't have fresh mushrooms which was a slight drawback but the sub overall was good. I think you need to take the other negative reviews with a grain of salt. This place is a typical solidly good CT pizza sun/grinder shop.
  
  Enjoy!

• James A.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 3 August 2026

  If you like buffalo chicken- DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE!!!! I ordered a buffalo chicken wrap- it came by delivery and was VERY SOGGY besides that the chicken was some sort of pink, not from being under cooked but from their terrible sauce. Being cut in half, the right side of the wrap had an average amount of chicken inside of it but the left half had 3 little chunks of chicken. I'm not exaggerating, I opened it up and found soggy lettuce, nasty blue cheese dressing and a mashed up tomato. Furthermore, the buffalo chicken tenders we ordered were disgusting!! Their sauce is atrocious and should not be consumed especially if you're expecting a BUFFALO sauce not some watered duck sauce sweet and sour sauce looking "hot sauce." Like I said before, this hot sauce dyes the chicken meat pink. I will not be ordering anything buffalo from here ever again.

• Brian G.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 28 July 2026

  Screwed up my order couldn't have been more specific, get it home and naturally it was wrong called to see if they would fix it and she gave me an attitude, right in the trash where the food belongs

• Ashley V.

  star star star star_border star_border 19 July 2026

  Ordered cause it was close and we wanted pizza. Was nothing special. Got the meat lovers pizza. Came in 30 mins so not terrible .

• TW S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 18 July 2026

  Stay away.  Literally got in an argument with them on the phone while ordering a pizza.  They had coupons in the 2019 Fitch Falcons Premium discount pack that are good until 3/31/20 (9 months from now) for a free small cheese pizza with the order of any large two topping pizza.  Initial argument was that coupon was only good during the baseball season - apparently the expiration date doesn't matter.  Additional argument regarding delivery ensued after they agreed to accept the coupon 'anyway'.  Anyway??? It isn't expired!  How the heck are you doing us a favor by accepting it 'anyway'?  Then they changed the story to 'you can use the coupon if you come pick it up'.  Apparently they weren't going to deliver it because they were already doing us a favor.  The only issue is they had multiple coupons in this Falcons Premium Discount pack and had delivered to us with a previous coupon. After being tired of arguing we finally hung up.  Five minutes later we get a call back with a message saying if you really want the pizza we'll sell it to you and deliver it.  Yeah - your pizza was only average without spit in it.  We ordered from you because you were one of the few places that deliver to our neighborhood.  We're done with you.  All because you wouldn't honor your own coupon for a free cheese pizza that's worth about $5.  Good luck to you...